Second molar replacement therapy
(SMRT) can be a very controversial issue. There are
three types of wisdom: 1. There is the wisdom of God
(the one true living God) 2. There is the wisdom of
the world 3. There is the wisdom of the devil. Believe
it or not, agree with it or not, like it or not, there
is a real supernatural being called the devil. He
is our adversary. He is a liar and a deceiver. He
does not want you to know the truth. He does not want
you to know what is right and best for you. His goal
is to destroy. He has great power and influence over
the world system (including health care) as we know
it today, but only as God allows.
True wisdom is from God. He is
our creator. He designed and made each one of us.
He knows us well individually and collectively. He
wants you to know the truth. He wants you to know
and do what is right and best for you. He is for you
and not against you. He will give us wisdom if we
ask for it, but we must believe in Him and trust in
Him when He answers us and not waiver or doubt when
He answers us (James 1:5-8).
When the benefits of SMRT are carefully and logically
considered, we believe that the proper decision should
be as the worldly saying goes, "a no brainer."
WHAT IS SECOND MOLAR REPLACMENT
THERAPY (SMRT)?
Second molar replacement
therapy (SMRT) is the process of removing the permanent
(adult) second molars and allowing the third molars
("wisdom" teeth) to erupt or grow into the
second molar places. There are normally four second
molars that are removed (one in each corner of the mouth)
and four third molars ("wisdom" teeth) that
take their place. Under normal circumstances, the "wisdom"
teeth will drift forward in due time and take the place
of the second molar.
 |
The "wisdom"
teeth normally erupt between 18 and 28 years of age.
SMRT will allow the "wisdom" teeth to erupt
earlier and better. With SMRT, "wisdom" teeth
will typically erupt around 16 years of age. We have
had one female patient whose "wisdom" teeth
began erupting at 14 years of age! One of the primary
reasons that "wisdom" teeth become impacted
is because they have no place to go as they try to develop
and erupt. The roots become all twisted and turned as
the tooth is locked between the second molar and the
surrounding bone of the upper and lower jaws. It is
even more of a problem in the lower jaw. This process
frees up the "wisdom" teeth or third molars
and allows them to develop as they should without hindrance
or restriction.
WHAT IS THE SUCCESS
RATE?
Under normal circumstances and with
proper case selection, the "success" rate
of SMRT in our personal experience with our own patients
is about 95 - 98 %. That is an excellent "success"
rate! What do we mean by "success"? We mean
that the "wisdom" teeth or third molars
essentially came in and took the place of the second
molars without any significant complications. When
dealing with the human body, nothing is guaranteed.
However, the predictability of SMRT is very good,
especially when certain criteria are met. You can
see the benefit of this technique from the unfinished
and finished case illustrations of our own patients
in this monograph and web site.
WHAT ARE
THE ORTHODONTIC BENEFITS OF SECOND MOLAR REPLACEMENT
THERAPY(SMRT)?
1. It provides immediate
space to work with and fewer teeth to move when uncrowding
teeth or correcting an over-bite and/or over-jet situation.
This is a direct and stark contrast to the process of
removing permanent premolars to make space which has
been an inherent part of "traditional" orthodontics
for decades and even still today (see our monograph
and web page on "Functional Orthodontics vs. Traditional
Orthodontics").
2. It reduces or eliminates
recrowding (orthodontic relapse) of teeth later on.
3. It frees up the "wisdom"
teeth so that they can develop normally without becoming
impacted or causing recrowding of the other teeth.
4. In open bite cases, it
can help to reduce or close the open bite.
5. A bigger, broader smile
compared to "traditional" orthodontics which
has removed premolars over the decades (see our monograph
on "Functional Orthodontics vs. Traditional Orthodontics")
6. A healthier TMJ (temporomandibular
joint or "jaw joint") compared to "traditional"
orthodontics (see our monograph as referenced in point
#5 above). SMRT in conjunction with "functional"
orthodontics develops the upper and lower jaws forward,
relieving the TMJ. Removal of premolars in "traditional"
orthodontics results in just the opposite. When the
premolar spaces are closed, the upper and lower jaws
are constrained or retarded (under developed), retruded
(brought back), or restricted. This is not good for
the TMJ. It causes an unhealthy situation for the TMJ
by causing it to be jammed when eating or clenching
or grinding the teeth. This effect of "traditional"
orthodontics either causes or aggravates TMJ problems!
7. SMRT removes only four
teeth rather than eight teeth (four premolars and four
"wisdom" teeth) as in the case of "traditional"
orthodontics.
WHAT ARE THE PRACTICAL
& FINANCIAL BENEFITS OF SECOND MOLAR REPLACEMENT
THERAPY (SMRT)?
1. Simple extractions vs.
complicated, surgical extractions
2. Less potential for post-op problems (pain, swelling,
dry socket, etc.)
3. Less cost
4. Quicker recovery and healing (because the patient
is much younger)
WHAT ARE
THE CRITERIA FOR SECOND MOLAR REPLACEMENT THERAPY (SMRT)?
To get the best results,
the following criteria should be satisfied:
1. There need to be "wisdom" teeth or third
molars to replace the second molars. Without "wisdom"
teeth to replace the second molars, we obviously do
not remove the second molars. The technique works best
when there are four second molars and four "wisdom"
teeth to work with (one of each in each corner of the
mouth). This results in a better, balanced bite. However,
we still get good results even if one or more "wisdom"
teeth are missing. It may not be the best case scenario,
but it is still better than the alternative.
2. We do not remove the second molars until they are
erupted enough to gain access to them for simple extraction
or removal. This avoids having to make an incision in
the gums for a more complicated surgical removal. The
second molars normally erupt around 12 years of age.
They are often called "12 year molars." The
timing of SMRT for orthodontic patients is normally
between Phase II (removable functional appliances) and
Phase III (brackets and wires or "braces").
3. Under normal and ideal circumstances, we get the
best result when the "wisdom" teeth are not
very well developed. The best time is usually when the
"wisdom" teeth have good crown development
and very little or no root development. This is best
determined with a panoramic radiograph ("xray").
The timing of SMRT for non-orthodontic patients is typically
sometime after the second molars have erupted (sometime
after 12 years of age).
We still get good results
and benefit with older patients who have more developed
"wisdom" teeth. These cases just take longer
to "finish" and are less predictable and less
perfect. However, the results are still better than
the alternative.
WHO IS A CANDIDATE FOR
SECOND MOLAR REPLACMENT THERAPY (SMRT)?
1. Those who satisfy the
above criteria.
2. Orthodontic patients with crowded teeth and/or over-bite/over-jet.
SMRT is an inherent part of our "Full Face Functional
Orthodontics." Potential orthodontic patients should
not even consider doing orthodontics with us without
commitment to second molar removal and replacement.
Don't start a project without counting the cost. Don't
start to cross a strong river unless you plan to go
to the other side. You can't stop mid-stream without
problems.
3. Non-orthodontic patients with potential for impacted
"wisdom" teeth.
Criteria for potential for impacted "wisdom"
teeth:
A. Panoramic radiograph analysis
B. One or both parents with a history of impacted "wisdom"
teeth
WHO IS NORMALLY
NOT A CANDIDATE FOR SECOND MOLAR REPLACEMENT THERAPY
(SMRT)?
1. The older patient with
fully developed and /or poorly positioned or impacted
"wisdom" teeth with a poor prognosis for replacement
of the second molars by the "wisdom" teeth.
(However, we have seen some amazing results with patients
who were not very good candidates for SMRT for various
reasons but still decided to opt for SMRT).
2. Those who are more comfortable with traditional or
conventional treatment modes.
3. Those who are not convinced that this is a better
way.
WHAT DO THE "NAY
SAYERS" SAY?
There are some lay people
as well as professionals who are antagonistic and vehemently
opposed to second molar replacement therapy (SMRT).
It amazes me how foolish some people can be when faced
with the truth and factual evidence. I call it willful
ignorance. Ignorance may seem like a strong word that
draws strong reaction, but it simply means "without
knowledge." These people simply have no working
knowledge about SMRT. All they have is head knowledge.
They don't know if it really works or not. They have
no experience.
Change is a difficult thing for most people. There are
usually two things that keep us from changing for the
better - pride and "comfort zone." We don't
want to think that we are not providing the best treatment
possible (pride). We have always done it a certain way
and we don't want to change because it's comfortable
to us that way ("comfort zone"). Some people
are bound and determined not to change, regardless of
the proof of benefit.
Unfortunately, some of our patients or potential patients
over the years have sought the counsel of these types
of people and have allowed them to badly influence their
decision. These are some of their arguments or the things
that the "nay sayers" say:
1. "We've never heard
of that."
Just because they've never heard of it, doesn't mean
that it's not the best treatment.
2. "We've never done that."
Just because they've never done it, doesn't mean that
it's not the best treatment.
3. "You're removing four perfectly good teeth."
Orthodontists have been removing "four perfectly
good teeth" (premolars) for decades. They turn
around and remove four more teeth later (four "wisdom"
teeth) to try to prevent recrowding of teeth. Some orthodontists
still do that today!
4. "Wisdom" teeth are not good to keep because
they are so badly malformed."
"Wisdom" teeth will not be malformed if they
are allowed to develop properly.
These "nay sayers"
do not want to know the truth. They are bound and determined
to believe a lie even in the face of obvious truth.
After careful consideration of the information provided
in this monograph and a careful review of the case presentations
of our actual patients, we hope that you can come to
the right conclusion and make the proper decision regarding
SMRT. As we mentioned in the beginning of this monograph,
true wisdom comes from God. We believe that what is
right and proper in this matter should be obvious -
a "no brainer."
This monograph was designed
with the patient in mind, but other health care professionals
should be able to benefit from this information also.
For even more fantastic information
on SMRT from two of the most revered pioneers of functional
orthodontics and SMRT, click on
the image to the left view illustrative case
studies and to read the terrific article "Treating
to Beautiful Faces, Healthyt TM Joints, Faster Treatments,
and Stable Arches" in the Journal of General Orthodontics
by Dr. John WitzigDDS and Dr. Yosh Jefferson, DMD, IBO.
|